← All projects

Modulator retention shapes

Ways of holding the modulators in a radial flux magnetic gear, and a proof of concept prototype that came within 2.5% of the FEA slip torque.

One of the biggest issues in magnetic gear design is finding a way to hold the modulator pieces in place. The air gaps between the modulator rotor and the inner and outer rotors are often in the order of 0.5 mm or 1 mm, which leaves very little space for a support structure. The structure cannot be ferromagnetic, since that would disrupt the magnetic fields going through the modulators. And the force on each modulator can be in the order of kilonewtons.

This project compared ways of retaining the modulators in a conventional radial flux magnetic gear, then designed and built a proof of concept prototype for Regal Rexnord to validate the FEA models. If you are new to magnetic gears, this short background may help.

Build

The modulator cage was 3D printed in carbon fiber reinforced polycarbonate. It took many versions to get the cage strong enough, and the final version has a thin bridge on both the inside and the outside to increase the stiffness. The housing was machined out of 6061 aluminum and the shafts out of non-magnetic 300 series stainless steel. The IPM rotor and the PM stator back irons are 29 gauge M19 silicon steel laminations.

Challenges

The modulators sit 1 mm from each of the PM rotors and experience very high forces, which made the overall design difficult. The modulator cage bent and deformed, and 3D printing tolerances were a problem.

Results

  • Slip torque of 76.2 N·m, within 2.5% of FEA
  • Continued operation after long periods at 1800 RPM

Papers

  • Comparison of Modulator Retention Shapes for Radial Flux Coaxial Magnetic GearsIEEE ECCE, 2022IEEE XplorePDF

Some figures on this page are from these papers. © IEEE.